The fundamental flaw with sports memoirs that Wallace noted is that they exist in an inherent state of tension between what readers want and what athletes can provide. Readers want insight into not just the lives of the authors but how their talents work and how their greatest moments felt. But top athletes’ greatness may stem entirely from the fact that they don’t think about such things — instinct, habit, stoicism, and ineffable natural talent are their stock and trade. Over-analysis is death.
“The real, many-veiled answer to the question of just what goes through a great player’s mind as he stands at the center of a hostile crowd-noise and lines up the free-throw that will decide the game might well be: nothing at all,” Wallace wrote.
